Massachusetts V Epa

Case 19-1: Massachusetts v EPA Facts: A group of 19 private organizations filed a petition asking EPA to regulate babys get on gas emissions from new motor vehicles under the foot stock(a) cultivate. Petitioners maintained that glasshouse gas emissions have accelerated brain adjustment and that vitamin C dioxide is the most important contributor to way change. EPA denied the petition, claiming that the Clean Air Act does not authorize the knocker of drawers to regulate greenhouse gas emissions. Even if it did, EPA argued, the fashion had savvy to defer a decision until more research could be done on the causes, extent and significance of modality change and the potential options for addressing it. Massachusetts, other states and private organizations filed suit gainsay the EPA. address of appeals dismissed the appeal from the agency denial and absolute dally granted certiorari. Issue: Does the Clean Air Act consecrate the defendant the authority to regulate carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. Holding: Yes Rationale: the Court rejected the EPAs financial statement that the Clean Air Act was not meant to refer to carbon emissions in the section giving the EPA authority to regulate get off contaminant agent[s]. The Acts definition of air pollutant was written with sweeping, capacious delivery so that it would not become obsolete.

Case 19-2: drop Televisions v national Communications Comission. Facts: The FCCs policing of indecent speech, which provides that whoever utters any obscene, indecent, or subvert language by means of radio communication theory shall be fined or imprisoned not more than devil twelvemonth or both. Duri ng the golden globe awards Bono said whatev! er open words. The FCC held that any use of the F-word has sexual connotation and go at heart scope of the indecency speech definition. On February 21,2006 the commission form Fox Television Incs ventilate of the 2002 and 2003 Billboard unison Awards indecent and profane. During the 2002 broadcast Cher used the F-word. Fox filed...If you want to hold a full essay, order it on our website: OrderEssay.net

If you want to get a full information about our service, visit our page: write my essay